Or was it Hayes threatening kids, and tenants with a gun for the rent. A firefighter moves into a family-friendly neighborhood with his wife and child, but the rambunctious teenagers living next door drive him over the edge. Why open that door again unless there's premeditation to end this dispute once and for all? Makes me SICK. A young family buys a rural piece of paradise, but the gate on their land that prevents neighbors from accessing their property becomes an angry, and ultimat. Offender: Robert BobLorenz, 54, military veteran, federal employee Shaffer said the Eldridge family has filed a $3.7 million lawsuit against Lorenz. A man who is meticulous about his lawn bickers with a new neighbor who doesn't have the same priorities; the feud between the two men escalates, ultimately ending in an episode of shocking violence. Hope your grandfather meets the devil and is taken below to burn in hell because thats exactly where he belongs. Man Who Shot Neighbor to Pay $30,000 Settlement acquittal unfair. A former cop moves into a close-knit neighborhood. In Carmel Canyon, California, wealthy neighbors get into disputes over a variety of issues from shared roads and bridges to the upkeep of their respective properties. (LogOut/ Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. As a veteran myself, I find it funny that Bob couldnt fight, but quickly pulled out a gun to kill this man. Instead of the new start he was hoping for, a man's move to. Location:Leesburg, Virginia control himself or think rationally. several opportunities to back down from the confrontation. The building of a backyard shed destroys a years-long close relationship between two neighbors and ignites a vicious conflict that sees property destroyed, pets killed, and finally, two people shot to death in cold blood. Robert Lorenz, 54, had said he shot Duren Wayne Eldridge on April 9 when the 31-year-old Eldridge came to his door and began threatening him. Under the terms of the agreement, Margaret Eldridge will receive $19,000 and $1,000 will go to her teenage daughter. -Kill-De-Sac, Fear Thy Neighbor (S2, E8), Date: April 9,1995 The jury heard a one-sided view of a neighbor she said was helpful and an autopsy report. said. Jeffrey Weigle and Dean Keller from Greenwood, Indiana,had been arguing and fighting for nearly a decade when, one day, in 2017, they pulled out their handguns and had a shootout over the fence in the yard. The conflict escalates until bullets fly and blood flows in the street. Brian Spinks Stabbed 60+ Times by Jealous Girlfriend; Kimethia Coleman Sentenced to Life in Prison, No Parole (January 17, 2010), Forensic Files Premiered 'Plastic Puzzle': Navy Veteran Kirk Hudson Struck & Killed in Hit-And-Run Accident in Kalamazoo, Michigan (June 1, 2005), Navy Veteran Christopher Ingraham Jr. Fatally Shot While Sleeping; Girlfriend Katrina Bridges Found Guilty, Sentenced to 47 Years (January 4, 2001). S8 E5 - Other People's Property. Your grandfather broke the law, took another human beings life and hes trying to play the victim. He told the cops that he shot them because he felt threatened. Eldridge's widow continued to live across the street from the Lorenz family A barrage of gunfire between the houses one night shatters both families forever. Loudon Verdict Fits Community Rot in hell Robert G. Lorenz because you are the Devils spawn for sure! Season 7 of the main series began on February 26, 2021, with the episode "Im Not Moving". Lorenz said he fired a .380-caliber semiautomatic pistol only after S8, Ep2. Robert Lorenz, 54, had said he shot Duren Wayne Eldridge on April 9 when the 31-year-old Eldridge came to his door and began threatening him. I dont remember this story.its sad though. A few months later, a car parked in Eldridge's driveway accidentally rolled into Lorenz's car-pool van. Betty Comerford, who lived next door to the Eldridges, called Lorenzs acquittal unfair. What starts as an idyllic relationship between neighboring best friends and business partners takes a wrong turn and ends up in threats, restraining orders, litigation and a triple homicide. But when the relationship sours, tensions build up and bullets fly. 'Fear Thy Neighbor' Season 6 released on Investigation Discovery on August 1, 2019. Fear Thy Neighbor is an American-Canadian true crime documentary television series which premiered on April 14, 2014 on the Investigation Discovery channel. This not only traumatized the young kids seeing Duren stumbling across the street and dropping dead on his front porch, it affected his entire family and friends. Prosecutors said Lorenz was in no danger from the unarmed Eldridge and had Location:Leesburg, Virginia Throughout the afternoon, Eldridge had complained loudly that Lorenz was a Lorenz's attorneys said he feared that Eldridge would attack him because Eldridge had threatened to enter the house and kill him. The men's feud leads to property damage, a backhoe attack, and ultimately, murder. family. A single woman and her two young sons believe they have found a perfect new apartment, but their overbearing landlord and neighbor soon turns their idyllic situation into a living hell that finally ends in bloodshed. When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. FEAR THY NEIGHBOR is a true crime documentary series that reveals what happens when a new homeowner unwittingly takes up residence within a stone's throw of a psycho, or when evil minds decide to lay down roots right next door. On the day the Eldridges moved in, their dogs relieved themselves on But juries sometimes neglect that standard, Wales said. The children survived, but their mother perished. Numerous heated debates between the neighbors eventually lead to murder. The conflict escalates until bullets fly and blood flows in the street. For those who prefer commercial free programming during your binge session, Prime Video has an ID channel: True Crime Files by Investigation Discovery available for $2.99 a month. Instead, prosecutors noted, Lorenz went back into his house after five minutes of arguing -- closing but not locking a glass storm door while Eldridge stood outside -- before emerging with his gun. A single mom and her four children find an ideal home in. Wallace was waiting in . "Immediately prior to the shot, they heard the words Don't come into my house,' " Shaffer said. This page was last edited on 4 February 2023, at 16:54. Margaret Eldridge, who has moved to California and could not be reached for comment, had asked for $3.75 million to compensate for her husband's lost wages, the loss of companionship and her child's loss of a father, Fleming said. S8 E3 - The Next Door War. The argument was the culmination of months of tension on Lounsbury Court, a quiet cul-de-sac with manicured lawns in northern Leesburg. Blizzard of Blood. Lorenz cried and hugged his family after the verdict in Loudoun County The stories unravel from the neighbor who takes over the property next door to the feuding best friends and business partners True crime show about conflicts between neighbors that go terribly wrong. A single mother gets along with her handyman neighbor, until her new boyfriend adopts more than 50 dogs. Man Acquitted in Slaying of Neighbor Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. A couple moves into their dream home on the same street where theyve lived for years, only to find themselves engulfed in a wrenching conflict with their neighbor who believes hes the rightful owner of their property. Lorenz's attorney argued that he feared Eldridge was about to attack him. He deserves to pay something for that, she said. Follow the links to read about more neighborly feuds that ended in murder. Prosecutors, who argued that the shooting was a premeditated act that followed months of bad blood, said Lorenz was never in danger and simply could have shut the door and called the police. Close the door. "It certainly is an unusual verdict," said Anne Coughlin, a University of Virginia visiting professor who specializes in criminal law. Lorenz' wife was in another room He would never have reacted like that. ``They have spent many a Two new homeowners work to restore their neighboring, derelict homes, but one of the renovations falls seriously behind and ultimately leads to murder. A defense psychologist testified that Lorenz so feared Eldridge that he was unable to think rationally. The teen-agers who congregated at the Eldridge household were a constant im Durens daughter thank u for your words. Lorenz testified he was scared and After killing Bob, Walt burned and attempted to hide his body in a bonfire on his property. We didn't have a running feud.". Fear Thy Neighbor is an American-Canadian true crime documentary television series which premiered on April 14, 2014 on the Investigation Discovery channel. "It was a tragedy for everyone involved. Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (Amazon) resolved itself,'' Shaffer said. report that a teen-ager visiting Eldridge's household had damaged Lorenz's Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (S2, E8) No sympathy for your evil grandfather. Danetta Henry was murdered by Alvin Dalton from Fresno, California. Hoyle had been in a long-term feud with his close neighbors for some time, but the police say that, on this occasion, he flew into a rage and lost control of his common senses. After three days of deliberations, the jury acquitted Lorenz of first-degree murder and several lesser charges. See production, box office & company info. He was a nice guy,'' she said. One witness told how DePaul and Dempsey were constantly harassed by the Hoyle couple every time they were in their yard. Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. Daniel Stewart, Jill Yousaf & Army Soldier James Catlin Conspired and Murdered Homeless Colorado Teen Maggie Fetty (November 30, 1991), Navy Master Chief John Bench Murdered Son & Attempted to Murder Wife & Daughter at Sasebo Naval Base in Japan; Died by Suicide in Motorcycle Crash (August 30, 2009), Army Spc. "Why not close the door and lock it? until last month. 2022. It's one person that is confrontational without reason and one surreptitiously annoying person. of convicting Lorenz of a lesser charge. Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (website) I hated them both, two asshats constantly riling each other up, though it looked like Coone was the biggest ass hat. Especially with how hard it is to find good step dads today and this amazing one lost his life standing ground for a safe place for the kids? Thinking about you today. Unlike in most self-defense shootings, Eldridge never displayed a weapon or entered Lorenz's house before he was fired upon. He definitely has a mental problem and he is a coward. My daddy was military. Battle lines are drawn, violence flares, and blood runs in the street. "I think everyone would acknowlege that the dollar figure in no way reflects the value and quality of Mr. Eldridge's life. MURDERER! Fear Thy Neighbor is in Delaware County in Pennsylvania to investigate the murder of Scott Robbins and the shooting of his stepdaughter, Kirsten Snow, by their neighbor, James (Jim) Dellavecchia. The jury could have convicted Lorenz of a lesser charge. A disabled fireman polices his neighbors, punishing them for violations ranging from loud music to off-leash dogs. said. On a quiet cul de sac, a contractor helps his neighbor rent the home beside him, unwittingly trapping himself between an increasingly unhinged presence on one side and the man's hostile parents on the other. bushes and flowers, neighbors said. A handyman, living rent-free in the home of a generous friend, grows increasingly paranoid about his neighbors; filming them constantly and fighting with them incessantly until conflict escalates out of control and culminates in explosive violence. The shooting was the culmination of months of tension between the quiet Lorenz, who works for the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and the raucous family renting the house across the street in suburban Washington. Just watched this one. -Lake of Madness, Fear Thy Neighbors (S2, E2), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Lake of Madness on Investigation Discovery: Paul Crawford Executed Family Next Door, Then Killed Himself (April 20, 2015), ID Go: When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. After an early retirement, a man buys a duplex and rents half of it out to a troubled family. Although Lorenz was charged with first-degree murder, the jury could have convicted him of second-degree murder or manslaughter. No true man would. One day, Dalton became enraged during an argument and opened fire with his handgun on Henry and her two teenage children. The Phillips' family moves to a quiet seafront town in Maine to escape a crime wave in Indiana. Where's the malice?". They can kill you with their hands.". Lorenz sought to recover costs for medical and legal bills that stemmed from the incident. Disposition:Lorenz claimed self-defense, justified shooting, acquitted of murder. ride his skateboard in front of Lorenz's house to aggravate the older man, and ``He fired a weapon. Eldridges blood alcohol level was 0.19, more than twice the limit for drivers. When a new tenant in a Harlem apartment building has his advances toward his upstairs neighbor rebuffed, his anger sets off a chain of accusations, threats and fights that culminate in bloodshed and shocking tragedy. Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger Eldridge, a truck driver, was upset that Lorenz had called the police to complain about teenage skateboarders who were visiting Eldridge's daughter. Man Acquitted in Slaying of Neighbor a child that's trying to piece together her life.". Homeowner Irving Galarza hopes the renters who move into the house beside him will be better behaved than the previous tenants were. Last month, she moved out of the neighborhood. Two women have lived next door to each other since childhood; then, one woman's ex-husband begins seeing the other woman, leading to a conflict; when property disputes are mixed in, the result is a shocking act of violence that engulfs them all. Editors note: With a cable subscription, you can download the free ID Go app and watch all of the Investigation Discovery programming at your convenience. Fear Thy Neighbor: Tony Coone vs. Bob Hayes. It's a conflict that will end in bloodshed. One woman's picture-perfect island sanctuary reveals itself to be filled with dangers in this exciting page-turner See production, box office & company info. Really tough arent you? Circumstances:Annoyed with dog peeing on his lawn, Durens car rolled into his car and hit it causing minor damage, kids on skateboards were too loud, Bob called police & complained about neighbors multiple times, Bob yelled at the kids at Durens house, during confrontation at Bobs front door, Bob shot Duren with handgun and Duren died When a freewheeling family moves from California to the buttoned down enclave of Leesburg, Virginia, they quickly get on the wrong side of their neighbour across the way. A man who shot a drunken neighbor in a dispute over unruly teen-age ", Anderson called the verdict "a disappointment.". In a tight-knit community, a new family commits a slight against a community member causing all of their neighbors to turn against them and leading to an explosive conclusion. In the countersuit, which was filed Feb. 26, Lorenz had accused Duren Eldridge of assault, intimidation and harassment. Fear Thy Neighbor explores nightmares that are living right next door. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Bob is/was and ALWAYS will be a a self-entitled MURDERER even in death. confused by Eldridge's rantings and threats. Legal specialists said a claim of self-defense generally requires evidence that the person first tried to retreat from a threat, which prosecutors said Lorenz did not do. Investigation Discovery's ' Fear Thy Neighbor: Bloodshed on Beattie Street' probes this very case through interviews of law enforcement officials and people that knew Tony. Wonder what happened to the murderer? Related Links: document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Fear Thy Neighbor Premiered Kill-De-Sac on Investigation Discovery: Robert Lorenz Shoots Duren Eldridge, Claims Self-Defense, Acquitted of Murder (June 1,2015), Jury Acquits Virginia Man Who Killed Neighbor, Fastidious Homeowner Acquitted of Murdering Raucous Neighbor, Man Who Shot And Killed Angry Neighbor Acquitted, Loudon Slaying Acquittal Greeted with Accolades and Anger, Man Who Shot Neighbor to Pay $30,000 Settlement, Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (S2, E8), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (website), Kill-De-Sac | Fear Thy Neighbor | Investigation Discovery (Amazon), Fear Thy Neighbor: 23 Veteran Cases Featured on Investigation Discovery. Lorenz and his wife cried yesterday as the verdict was read. Neighbors take sides after someone decides to build a dream home on their quiet street; longtime friends turn into hardcore enemies, and death is right around the corner. One neighbor takes the dispute to new levels when he hires a hitman to permanently solve the problem. ``It's obviously a verdict I'm disappointed in,'' Commonwealth's Attorney Eldridge was angry because Lorenz a few days earlier had called police to A rash of break-ins shatters the peace in a tight-knit community; when residents take sides, good friends turn into deadly enemies. Fear Thy Neighbor is in the Frankford area of Philadelphia, PA, to examine the murders of Bob DePaul and his partner August Dempsey by their neighbor Kenneth Hoyle in 2017. A wealthy executive causes conflict after forbidding his neighbors access to his extensive lands; one local handyman fights to keep the roads and trails open for all, a struggle that ends when one man lies dead. -Red Picket Fences, Fear Thy Neighbor (S1, E2) But increasing conflict with his neighbor eventually led to his tragic death. Example: person says keep your dog off mg lawn, dog owner lets dog run free then feels victimized when the neighbor comes at him. A defense psychologist testified Lorenz was so gripped by fear he could not working on his boat, neighbors said. A former police chief who owns most of the homes on his street gets into constant conflict with a young renter who doesn't respect his authority. I live near Frankford. Lorenz said he agreed to settle because the costs of the dispute were becoming overwhelming. True crime show about conflicts between neighbors that go terribly wrong.True crime show about conflicts between neighbors that go terribly wrong.True crime show about conflicts between neighbors that go terribly wrong. A U.S. Army veteran goes out of his way to make his neighbors feel welcome, but when a child's birthday gift goes missing, it takes only 37 days for the friendships to end in a killing spree.